popcornmonsters.com
login
username
password
|
   Welcome, | |

 

  Netflix, Inc.
Carnival of Souls - Criterion Collection
overview reviews rating cast images links contributors  
Carnival of Souls - Criterion Collection
 
Writen By:anonymous
Date:2008-04-10
Name:Carnival of Souls - Criterion Collection
Image:Image
Buy Now:Buy Now For $39.95 (price as of 2008-04-10)
Rating:5 out of 5
Summary:CRITERION vs. IMAGE ENTERTAINMENT DVD (FANS WILL WANT TO CHECK THIS OUT)
Full Review:
Get ready, `cause this is gonna get complicated (real fast, lol).



Okay, so you have both Criterion and Image Entertainment releasing the same movie in the same year; a film that until then, had only known cruddy, "Public Domain", hell (on TV, $0.99 VHS and $1.99 DVD's) and with pretty much the same remastered picture quality, right?



Well here's where it gets very odd; the, Criterion set, has two versions of the film, a 78 minute theatrical version and an 83 minute Director's Cut, where as the Image Entertainment DVD has a running time of 82 minutes (note: all of the actual discs, corroborate, the DVD cases, printed running times).



So, one would assume that the Image disc, was culled from the same print used to create the Criterion, Director's Cut, seeing as the run times are so close, and as previously mentioned, the prints look very much the same...



...but you would be wrong.



The reason being, is that both of the Criterion versions have a scene near the beginning of the film where a police/detective, person, is interviewing the driver of the second car in the opening drag race, asking the driver his version of the events on the bridge, but this scene is absent from the Image version.



Now granted, this is a little 10 second scene, but it dose rise the question as to where Image got this pristine print from (as there are no restoration notes on the Image packaging) and why does it very from the theatrical version in this one scene (possibly others as well, but I've yet to do any serious, frame-by-frame, comparisons to all three films because, well, I do have a life, lol).



The scene in question is actually quite redundant, as we already have witnessed the events on the bridge, and know what happened, and it's non-inclusion in the Image version is seamlessly done, making it look, for all the world, like the scene was an added scene for the Director's Cut of the, Criterion version, but since this scene is also in the theatrical cut, one has to wonder (once again) where the Image print came from (and how much more is different between the three versions, for that matter).



Then there's the running time issues, as you would assume that the Image DVD would be the theatrical cut (possibly licensed from Criterion to provide a cheap alternative to the Criterion set, as was done with the movie, Zombi, which both Blue Underground and Shriek Show paid to have the film restored, and one put out a low priced, movie only DVD at the same time that the other put out a two disc special edition version) but where as the theatrical cut is 78 minutes, and it's Director's Cut is 83 minutes, the Image disc is 82 minutes (and is missing at least one scene that both the theatrical and Director's Cuts have).



This is curious, and just thought that fans might want to know, or might even have some ideas, as to the nature of the Image DVD.


Date PM Rating ( # Votes )RatingReviewer
07/26/2009 View Review - 2/10 Derek_Fleek
08/19/2005 View Review - 3/10 magdalena

Other Reviews

DateNameRating
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls - Criterion Collection Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls - Criterion Collection Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls - Criterion Collection Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls - Criterion Collection Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls - Criterion Collection Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 2 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 2 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival Of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival Of Souls Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival Of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival Of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival Of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls and Horror Hotel Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls and Horror Hotel Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls and Horror Hotel Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls and Horror Hotel Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls and Horror Hotel Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 2 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 2 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls (1962) (B&W) Review 3 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls (1962) (B&W) Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls (1962) (B&W) Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls (1962) (B&W) Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls (1962) (B&W) Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-23 View Carnival of Souls Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-23 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-23 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-23 View Carnival of Souls Review 3 out of 5
2008-04-23 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-11 View AMC Monsterfest Collection - Cult Classics, Vol. 1 (The Atomic Brain / The Brain That Wouldn't Die / Carnival of Souls / Night Tide) Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-11 View AMC Monsterfest Collection - Cult Classics, Vol. 1 (The Atomic Brain / The Brain That Wouldn't Die / Carnival of Souls / Night Tide) Review 1 out of 5
2008-04-11 View AMC Monsterfest Collection - Cult Classics, Vol. 1 (The Atomic Brain / The Brain That Wouldn't Die / Carnival of Souls / Night Tide) Review 4 out of 5
2008-04-11 View AMC Monsterfest Collection - Cult Classics, Vol. 1 (The Atomic Brain / The Brain That Wouldn't Die / Carnival of Souls / Night Tide) Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-11 View AMC Monsterfest Collection - Cult Classics, Vol. 1 (The Atomic Brain / The Brain That Wouldn't Die / Carnival of Souls / Night Tide) Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-23 View Nat Pwe: Burma's Carnival of Spirit Soul Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-17 View Carnival of Souls / Invisible Ghost Review 3 out of 5
2008-05-08 View Carnival of Souls (Digitally Remastered) Review 5 out of 5
2008-05-08 View Carnival of Souls (Digitally Remastered) Review 4 out of 5
2008-05-08 View Carnival of Souls (Digitally Remastered) Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 3 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 1 out of 5
2008-04-10 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5
2008-04-23 View Carnival of Souls Review 5 out of 5

Carnival of Souls Forums
TopicsRepliesViewsAuthorLast Post
There are no Topics.
Posters
Carnival of Souls Masterprint
$14.99
Buy Now!
Northern Soul Art Print
$14.99
Buy Now!
Northern Soul Poster
$6.99
Buy Now!
Soul Children - Chronicle Wall Mural
$124.99
Buy Now!
Sweet Soul Music Wall Mural
$124.99
Buy Now!
Soul Children - Hold On, I
$124.99
Buy Now!
Professional Criterion Bicycle Giclee Print
$99.99
Buy Now!
See More >>
ad
Free Math Homework Help
Math Assignment
Webmasters Make $$$
Webmasters Make $$$
Affordable Webhosting at HostingViper.com